Dear Lisa Hanna and the youth group, The Jamaica Youth Advocacy Network (JYAN), I see what you are trying to say about the “outdatedness” of the “abortion law ” and the rights of women but some of your arguments for the changing and the ultimate legalization of the act (abortion) need to be revisited and subsequently discarded. The Offence Against the Persons Act , even though it states that abortion is illegal, does allow it in cases of rape,incest,abnormal defects of fetus or danger to the mother. Changing, adjusting or legalizing the abortion law or the act of undertaking to allow for termination of unplanned and “unwanted” pregnancy because it contributes to poverty, is an argument that I personally think is just plain ridiculous.
I do,however, agree that a woman should have the right to choose whether or not to bring forth a child in this world, but I do not agree with the utilization of the legalization of abortion as a means to stem the social problems of teenage pregnancy,crime and poverty.Why is that, policy makers and law makers, always try to fix a problem rather than to prevent it? And why is it that the blame is solely on the shoulders of the inner-city youths ?Is the problem not , extended to rural areas too?I know it does and so it’s time to stop picking out these teenagers and crucifying them as not every person that comes from the ghetto is a “bad seed’.
According to Madden (JYAN), a research done by his organization in 2005(nearly 10 years ago on approximatley 600 patients at Ward 5 (‘abortion ward” ) at victoria Jubilee,) revealed that all person were from inner-city communities, single, and a third were teenagers,”.Additionally, about 40 per cent had a previous termination of pregnancy and 30 per cent had two or more previous abortions http://www.jamaicaobserver.com/news/Youth-group-calls-for-legalisation-of-abortion#ixzz2WhyG6Pft. Even though this is a small sample when compared the approximately 3 million people living in Jamaica, the figure of 40% “repeat offenders” clearly paints a telling picture : the legalization of abortion WILL NOT solve the social problem of teenage pregnancy or”unwanted pregnancy” and so it is the imperative that “root” of these social problems be identified and addressed.
Rather than encourage our teenagers to have abortion because the child is going to be “unwanted” and will eventually not be cared for and thus left to be a criminal thereby contributing to the cycle of poverty , why not consider the making legislation from the following suggestions:
1. Make the use of chastity belt legal and obligatory to wear from the start of menses to the age of 18th.
2. Make it mandatory by law for teenagers to be given the one year injectable birth control. (the abstinence make sense campaign hasn’t done much to prevent teenage pregnancy so divert the resources to this suggestion).
3.Make it legal for carnal and Incest offenders to be castrated :).
4. Give the teenagers free lunch money and pocket money so that they stop having sex with the taxi drivers and sugar daddy for such.
5. “Invent”some deadly teenage sexual transmitted disease ( that only teenagers get from having unprotected/protected sex as a means of deterrence,thereby scaring them into abstinence .
Such measures, though unconventional ,will ultimately put a dent in the social problem of teenage pregnancy and subsequently the doing away of this “unwanted child phenomenon” that you, Hannah spoke about.As far as, preventing unplanned and unwanted pregnancy for the rest of the population (18 and up),all mi haffi seh is dawg nyam fi suppa.